News:

BREAKING NEWS:  Dream Theater reunites with drummer Mike Portnoy (10/25/23)

Main Menu

DT the League 2015 - Division 1, Week 14

Started by Destiny Of Chaos, March 18, 2015, 02:23:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Please vote for the song that you'd like to see win each of the numbered matches.

1. Pull Me Under
10 (40%)
1. The Glass Prison
15 (60%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
2. The Great Debate
14 (56%)
2. Overture 1928
11 (44%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
3. Bridges in the Sky
9 (36%)
3. The Mirror
16 (64%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
4. Disappear
11 (44%)
4. Stream of Consciousness
14 (56%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
5. Blind Faith
9 (36%)
5. Finally Free
16 (64%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
6. Trial of Tears
12 (48%)
6. Home
12 (48%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
7. In the Presence of Enemies
5 (20%)
7. Learning to Live
20 (80%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
8. Illumination Theory
11 (44%)
8. In the Name of God
13 (52%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
9. Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence
19 (76%)
9. Fatal Tragedy
6 (24%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
10. The Count of Tuscany
14 (56%)
10. Hell's Kitchen
11 (44%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
11. Take the Time
18 (72%)
11. Beyond This Life
6 (24%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
12. Metropolis
23 (92%)
12. Under a Glass Moon
2 (8%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
13. Lines in the Sand
13 (52%)
13. Space-Dye Vest
13 (52%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
14. The Spirit Carries On
5 (20%)
14. Octavarium
20 (80%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
15. Voices
13 (52%)
15. Scarred
12 (48%)
---Next Match below---
0 (0%)
16. Breaking All Illusions
13 (52%)
16. A Change of Seasons
12 (48%)

Total Members Voted: 25

Voting closed: March 20, 2015, 02:23:26 PM

Destiny Of Chaos

DT the League 2015 - Division 1, Week 14

Please vote for the song that you'd like to see win each of the numbered matches.

These are 16 head to head matches. You shouldn't be voting for your 16 most favorite overall. You should be voting for one song in each matchup... meaning one of the songs with a "1." in front of it, one of the songs with a "2." in front of it, an so on all the way to one of the songs with "16." in front of it.

You don't have to vote for a song in each match if you don't want to, whether you can't choose between the two, or don't like either etc. Individual matches can have less votes than the total number of people who voted, but they shouldn't have more.

Please double-check your ballot before submitting it.

If you have any questions about anything in regards to properly voting, please ask BEFORE voting.

If you realize that you made a mistake after voting, please let us know, so we know what to fix.


If you want to, you can reply with what you voted for... and we can discuss the match ups.  :tup



1.   Pull Me Under vs. The Glass Prison
2.   The Great Debate vs. Overture 1928
3.   Bridges in the Sky vs. The Mirror
4.   Disappear vs. Stream of Consciousness
5.   Blind Faith vs. Finally Free
6.   Trial of Tears vs.#13  Home
7.   In the Presence of Enemies vs. #7 Learning to Live
8.   #16 Illumination Theory vs. #15 In the Name of God
9.   #6 Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence vs. Fatal Tragedy 
10.   #14 The Count of Tuscany vs. Hell's Kitchen
11.   #4 Take the Time vs. Beyond This Life
12.   #5 Metropolis vs. Under a Glass Moon
13.   #12 Lines in the Sand vs. #11 Space-Dye Vest
14.   #10 The Spirit Carries On vs. #1 Octavarium
15.   #9 Voices vs. #8 Scarred
16.   #3 Breaking All Illusions vs. #2 A Change of Seasons


I've got to say... this week has a lot of great match ups.

You have 48 hours to vote!

Outcrier

1.   Pull Me Under vs. The Glass Prison
2.   The Great Debate vs. Overture 1928
3.   Bridges in the Sky vs. The Mirror
4.   Disappear vs. Stream of Consciousness
5.   Blind Faith vs. Finally Free
6.   Trial of Tears vs.#13  Home
7.   In the Presence of Enemies vs. #7 Learning to Live
8.   #16 Illumination Theory vs. #15 In the Name of God
9.   #6 Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence vs. Fatal Tragedy 
10.   #14 The Count of Tuscany vs. Hell's Kitchen
11.   #4 Take the Time vs. Beyond This Life
12.   #5 Metropolis vs. Under a Glass Moon
13.   #12 Lines in the Sand vs. #11 Space-Dye Vest
14.   #10 The Spirit Carries On vs. #1 Octavarium
15.   #9 Voices vs. #8 Scarred
16.   #3 Breaking All Illusions vs. #2 A Change of Seasons

CharlesPL

1.   Pull Me Under
2.   The Great Debate
3.   The Mirror
4.   Disappear
5.   Finally Free
6.   Trial of Tears
7.   Learning to Live
8.   Illumination Theory
9.   Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence
10.   The Count of Tuscany
11.   Take the Time
12.   Metropolis
13.   Space-Dye Vest
14.   Octavarium
15.   Scarred
16.   A Change of Seasons

Dublagent66

1.   The Glass Prison
2.   The Great Debate
3.   The Mirror
4.   Stream of Consciousness
5.   Blind Faith
6.   Trial of Tears
7.   Learning to Live
8.   In the Name of God
9.   Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence
10.   The Count of Tuscany
11.   Take the Time
12.   Metropolis
13.   Lines in the Sand
14.   Octavarium
15.   Scarred
16.   Breaking All Illusions

That last matchup was the toughest.  Sorry ACOS.  Had to go with BAI this time.  If ACOS wins, I'm still fine with that.


-AAgent66

425

1.   Pull Me Under
2.   Overture 1928
3.   Bridges in the Sky
4.   Stream of Consciousness
5.   Finally Free
6.   Trial of Tears
7.   #7 Learning to Live
8.   #15 In the Name of God
9.   #6 Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence
10.   #14 The Count of Tuscany
11.   #4 Take the Time
12.   #5 Metropolis
13.   #11 Space-Dye Vest
14.   #1 Octavarium
15.   #8 Scarred
16.   #3 Breaking All Illusions

Several tough ones. #16 was not one of them, that's an easy choice for BAI. #3, #8 and #13 were very hard choices to make, though.

Prog Snob

1.   The Glass Prison - I'm not the biggest fan of PMU and TGP is a kickass start to one of DT's best releases.
2.   The Great Debate - Another top track from 6DOIT
3.   Bridges in the Sky - The chorus alone in this song pushes it above The Mirror.
4.   Stream of Consciousness - I love what everyone dislikes about this song
5.   Finally Free - Tough choice but the closing track on Met. 2 is one of their best songs
6.   Home - I love ToT but the riff heavy Home is excellent
7.   Learning to Live - One of their best ever
8.   Illumination Theory - Masterpiece
9.   Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence - No explanation needed
10.   The Count of Tuscany - Rush-influenced and epic. The ending guitar solo is the second best solo on the CD
11.   Take the Time - Another easy choice
12.   Metropolis - My favorite DT song
13.   Space-Dye Vest - This was a tough choice but the mood of this song is perfect
14.   Octavarium - A really tough choice for me but I went with the epic
15.   Voices - Lyrically speaking, one of JPs best moments
16.   A Change of Seasons - My 2nd favorite DT song.

Evermind

1.   Pull Me Under vs. The Glass Prison
2.   The Great Debate vs. Overture 1928
3.   Bridges in the Sky vs. The Mirror
4.   Disappear vs. Stream of Consciousness
5.   Blind Faith vs. Finally Free
6.   Trial of Tears vs.#13  Home
7.   In the Presence of Enemies vs. #7 Learning to Live
8.   #16 Illumination Theory vs. #15 In the Name of God
9.   #6 Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence vs. Fatal Tragedy 
10.   #14 The Count of Tuscany vs. Hell's Kitchen
11.   #4 Take the Time vs. Beyond This Life
12.   #5 Metropolis vs. Under a Glass Moon
13.   #12 Lines in the Sand vs. #11 Space-Dye Vest
14.   #10 The Spirit Carries On vs. #1 Octavarium
15.   #9 Voices vs. #8 Scarred
16.   #3 Breaking All Illusions vs. #2 A Change of Seasons
Quote from: Train of Naught on May 28, 2020, 10:57:25 PMThis first band is Soen very cool swingy jazz fusion kinda stuff.

hefdaddy42

1.   The Glass Prison
2.   Overture 1928
3.   Bridges in the Sky
4.   Disappear
5.   Blind Faith
6.   Trial of Tears
7.   Learning to Live
8.   Illumination Theory
9.   Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence 
10.   Hell's Kitchen
11.   Take the Time
12.   Metropolis
13.   Lines in the Sand
14.   Octavarium
15.   Scarred
16.   A Change of Seasons
Quote from: BlobVanDam on December 11, 2014, 08:19:46 PMHef is right on all things. Except for when I disagree with him. In which case he's probably still right.

BlackInk

1.   Pull Me Under vs. The Glass Prison
2.   The Great Debate vs. Overture 1928
3.   Bridges in the Sky vs. The Mirror
4.   Disappear vs. Stream of Consciousness
5.   Blind Faith vs. Finally Free
6.   Trial of Tears vs.#13  Home
7.   In the Presence of Enemies vs. #7 Learning to Live
8.   #16 Illumination Theory vs. #15 In the Name of God
9.   #6 Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence vs. Fatal Tragedy
10.   #14 The Count of Tuscany vs. Hell's Kitchen
11.   #4 Take the Time vs. Beyond This Life
12.   #5 Metropolis vs. Under a Glass Moon
13.   #12 Lines in the Sand vs. #11 Space-Dye Vest
14.   #10 The Spirit Carries On vs. #1 Octavarium
15.   #9 Voices vs. #8 Scarred
16.   #3 Breaking All Illusions vs. #2 A Change of Seasons

Matches 5 and 6 were really tough. Also, as much as I like to see BAI do well, I don't like seeing it leading over ACoS.

RoeDent

What is it with match 16 always being a heavyweight clash? If we still did Match of the Week, that would most certainly be it!

GO BAI!

hefdaddy42

Quote from: BlackInk on March 19, 2015, 12:51:15 PM
as much as I like to see BAI do well, I don't like seeing it leading over ACoS.
Same here, and it's a little surprising, but vox populi and all that.
Quote from: BlobVanDam on December 11, 2014, 08:19:46 PMHef is right on all things. Except for when I disagree with him. In which case he's probably still right.

erwinrafael

Space Dye Vest vs. Lines in the Sand is tied right now, but it has an extra vote. Revote!  ;)

Prog Snob

Quote from: erwinrafael on March 20, 2015, 07:02:41 AM
Space Dye Vest vs. Lines in the Sand is tied right now, but it has an extra vote. Revote!  ;)

Okay Florida

RoeDent

#13
I can't bear to watch 16... :fingernails

UPDATE: It's held on! Breaking All Illusions has defeated the mighty A Change of Seasons, by just one vote! Is this ACOS's first ever regular season loss? Still, a historic moment, and one that continue's BAI's unstoppable rise to the upper echelon of DT classics.

425


Evermind

Yeah! I was definitely rooting for BAI here.
Quote from: Train of Naught on May 28, 2020, 10:57:25 PMThis first band is Soen very cool swingy jazz fusion kinda stuff.

TheCountOfNYC

An with that loss by A Change of Seasons, Octavarium may have just clinched the top spot since it already beat Breaking All Illusions. Can someone say repeat?

RoeDent

Quote from: TheCountOfNYC on March 20, 2015, 02:59:08 PM
An with that loss by A Change of Seasons, Octavarium may have just clinched the top spot since it already beat Breaking All Illusions. Can someone say repeat?

With 6 weeks still to run, there's still the chance of Octavarium vs ACOS. I think that's the only chance of it losing its perfect record, unless a remarkable upset happens vs another song.

TheCountOfNYC

Quote from: RoeDent on March 20, 2015, 03:08:22 PM
Quote from: TheCountOfNYC on March 20, 2015, 02:59:08 PM
An with that loss by A Change of Seasons, Octavarium may have just clinched the top spot since it already beat Breaking All Illusions. Can someone say repeat?

With 6 weeks still to run, there's still the chance of Octavarium vs ACOS. I think that's the only chance of it losing its perfect record, unless a remarkable upset happens vs another song.

It would be interesting if ACoS beats 8VM. That would mean the top 3 would all have one loss with Octavarium having beaten Breaking All Illusions, Breaking All Illusions having beaten A Change of Seasons, and A Change of Seasons having beaten Octavarium. We'll see what happens, but I'm rooting for 8VM to win it all.

Destiny Of Chaos

Quote from: RoeDent on March 19, 2015, 01:47:00 PM
What is it with match 16 always being a heavyweight clash? If we still did Match of the Week, that would most certainly be it!

GO BAI!

I've been treating Match 16 as Match of the Week. This week didn't fail to deliver.  :metal

Destiny Of Chaos

Quote from: erwinrafael on March 20, 2015, 07:02:41 AM
Space Dye Vest vs. Lines in the Sand is tied right now, but it has an extra vote. Revote!  ;)


Yeah, that's not good. I guess the score really is 13-12, but who knows which song was supposed to have the 13. Draw it is  :\

Dublagent66

Most match ups add up to 25.  Some only add up to 24 and a couple others are 26. :wtf:

425

By my count just the one (SDV vs. LITS) adds up to 26. Three of them add up to 24 (TTT vs. BTL, ToT vs. Home, ITNOG vs. IT). Which I assume means two people abstained from voting in one of the matches (or accidentally skipped one), while someone did not follow the instructions correctly (which I don't see how anyone could still mess it up given how clearly DOC has spelled it out).

fischermasamune

Maybe someone didn't vote in a match because it was a tie of songs they don't like, and voted on both for another pair of songs they love it.

hefdaddy42

Quote from: fischermasamune on March 22, 2015, 09:47:52 AM
Maybe someone didn't vote in a match because it was a tie of songs they don't like, and voted on both for another pair of songs they love it.
Maybe someone shouldn't have done that.

QuoteYou don't have to vote for a song in each match if you don't want to, whether you can't choose between the two, or don't like either etc. Individual matches can have less votes than the total number of people who voted, but they shouldn't have more.
Quote from: BlobVanDam on December 11, 2014, 08:19:46 PMHef is right on all things. Except for when I disagree with him. In which case he's probably still right.

fischermasamune

Quote from: hefdaddy42 on March 23, 2015, 07:18:30 AM
Quote from: fischermasamune on March 22, 2015, 09:47:52 AM
Maybe someone didn't vote in a match because it was a tie of songs they don't like, and voted on both for another pair of songs they love it.
Maybe someone shouldn't have done that.

My post really seems to indicate guilt, so I'll clarify: it was pure speculation of my part: I didn't do it. :)

hefdaddy42

Quote from: BlobVanDam on December 11, 2014, 08:19:46 PMHef is right on all things. Except for when I disagree with him. In which case he's probably still right.