News: Track-by-track video for Fall Into the Light:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ezfzdMpRc0

A nobody guitarist in a nobody band has enough smug sense of inflated ego as to bash Dream Theater?  Why am I not surprised?  Guitar players of his ilk are literally a dime a dozen.  I could likely download an app that would be more useful to me, guitar-wise than Wes Borland would be.

Trust me, he wasn't relevant then, either.

Yawn.  I didn't even know who Wes Borland was before I opened this thread.

Lol.

Whether you're in a band lots of people don't like or not, and whether you're talking about a band I think is great or not, I don't think it comes across very well to say things like "No, they just suck, fact." In fact the same thing applies to everyone trying to put their opinions across as fact (especially if they're rude about it), but for a famous musician it's even more embarassing.

Yawn.  I didn't even know who Wes Borland was before I opened this thread.

Same. I thought it might be some other prog musician, but this is far funnier.

Loads of people hate Dream Theater! His prerogative, would've been more surprised if he loved them, honestly. Judging by his own music, I think we'll be alright without him.

Still! Good luck if you're reading this, Wes. You hang in there - just keep clinging onto that last fibre of relevance.

I was going to make a thread about this too but wasn't sure if it was worth it. I think this is hillarious though

Seriously just go to Wes Borland's twitter and scroll down to 4/20 and read all the tweets/replies etc.
Def. some entertaining stuff

https://twitter.com/#!/wesborland

And regardless of his popularity, I wouldn't care about the opinion of someone in a different genre, especially one from such a short lived and extremely dated genre, who has only displayed a fraction of the longevity of DT.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

HAH


Hahaahahahaahaha.ahaah..haaa.ha...ahaa.......a....h....................................................

HAHAHAHHAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhughhhh...hah............ *coughs and wheezes for air*

What a moron

Well that's really funny that he considers himself worth enough to comment about real musicians.

I hate the "Feeling and soul over technique and speed" argument. Since when are they mutually exclusive?

Anyway, this guy sounds like a tool.

This reminds me of a monthly article they used to run in Guitar for the Practicing Musician magazine.  It was called "In The Listening Room".  They'd play the people or person a bunch of different songs and get their opinions on what they'd heard.  One month, they had Christopher Thorn and Rogers Stevens from Blind Melon.  They played Pull Me Under for them.  Here's what they had to say:

Christopher: This could be metal at any moment--I'm just warning everybody.

Rogers: Either that or it could build up into a power ballad.

C: I feel like we might have to excuse ourselves here for a second. We might have to leave.

R: This is one of those guitar sounds that when he hits a note, about a million lights jump up on his guitar rig.

C: Any minute now there is gonna be a squealy.

R: Is this, like, Queensryche?

C: If it is, let's turn it off right away because I hate that band.

R: Hate it. This is the kind of music you listen to right when you start to get your pubic hairs.

C: I can't even be fair to this music, I hate it so bad. I can't even sit through one song. I know I'm not being fair but I think it is complete garbage. That sort of guitar playing is just stupid.

R: If I want to hear a metal band I really like old Black Sabbath and Soundgarden, heavy bands with brains. If I were listening to an angry metal band I would be more into Rage Against the Machine or Sugar. I like that Sugar record a lot, I like Sonic Youth a lot. That's heavy, guitar based music that I listen to.

C: Playing fast for the sake of fast is hideous. I hate that whole mentality of sitting around playing scales and cock-rock crap.

R: I heard some squealies. I don't really like that sound either. I'm not into those guitar sounds. When I hear that stuff I get feeling squeamish.

Guitar: That was Dream Theater.

C: We'll remember not to buy that record. I bet they have really nice hair... now I'm being mean.

R: This is just our opinion. There's a lot of people that like Dream Theater and that's fine. They get off on it--good for them. They'll probably hate us, maybe they won't.

C: They probably do because we sound like we're playing sloppy. But that's alright, that's a different thing.  We're just coming from a different space.

R: In no way do we condemn this sort of music. These people have a right to exist.

C: Just keep it the hell away from us.

Quote from: BlobVanDam on April 23, 2012, 12:11:39 PM

such a short lived and extremely dated genre

I disagree with this. Deftones's Diamond Eyes proved that there are still exciting possibilities for nu metal.

Regarding Borland, I find it sad that, in 2012, some people still have the mindset that technical music cannot convey emotion, but he is entitled to his opinion. However, he expressed it in the worst possible way.

It's an idiotic opinion. There is no reason why anyone with a modicum of artistic inclination should believe such nonsense. It's almost illogical. There are people who DO use technique to the exclusion of emotion (just for sport). But that doesn't mean there aren't people who don't do that. Unlike LB, DT is actually a band that puts effort in and is emotionally invested in their music. What's next? Someone will come along and say painting with more than 2 colors can only exist to the exclusion of emotional investment.

It's absolutely stupid.

I used to like Wes Borland a lot as a guitarist and found his riff writing on the first 3 albums to be very clever and the only reason LP enjoyed any success briefly before he left them the first time. I respected him when he left the group cause he hated the direction they were going but a decade later when he needed cash he returned heh
The thing is that we have people who're fans of DT who said much worse things about DT than that, hell MP said worse things than that. The guy doesn't like their music writing and didn't attack them personally or anything so I can disagree with his opinion as I obviously do but find no need to make a big enough fuss. Horay for the internet rock news websites as usual.

we have people who're fans of DT who said much worse things about DT than that

It's like high school.  You can complain all day long about how much your school sucks, but the second a rival high school student says a bad word about your school, it's fucking ON.

That whole post GuiatarCosmo made didn't really bother me since I too feel Pull Me Under isn't really good at all.

Quote from: theseoafs on April 23, 2012, 01:05:14 PM

Quote from: Sir GuitarCozmo on April 23, 2012, 01:02:51 PM

R: Hate it. This is the kind of music you listen to right when you start to get your pubic hairs.

What does this even mean?

Immature, childish, trying to be cool to much.

This interview was in 1994, so unfortunately, there wasn't much better DT to choose from.